Skip to main content

How to add farmhouse appeal to an otherwise drab, boring mantel

Farmhouse styles feature cozy decor, timeless pieces, and homey interiors. And when it comes to your fireplace, you want this same energy to flow into your space so you can enjoy all that farm homes have to offer. Unfortunately, nailing the perfect fireplace mantel decor can be tricky. It’s hard to find a balance between incorporating sweet and subtle home furnishings and going overboard with all the fine details. Here are some tips and tricks to help you take your farmhouse mantel decor from drab and boring to cozy and inviting.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Try decorating with metal milk jugs

A classic decor piece for farmhouse fireplaces is a milk jug. Now, we’re not talking about the plastic cartons you buy at the grocery store! Instead, decorative metal milk jugs that have a vintage flair are the perfect addition to your fireplace mantel. You can find milk jugs of nearly any size at your local home goods store, so you’ll be able to find the perfect piece to place atop your mantel.

Recommended Videos

When decorating with milk jugs, we recommend sticking to timeless pieces. Opt for a sleek, vintage metal milk jug that looks slightly antiqued. Or use black or white painted jugs to suit your existing color palette. Since milk jugs bring an eclectic touch, you don’t need to go overboard with colors to draw attention to the decor. Instead, add two or three small milk jugs on your mantel, and use them in place of vases to hold lovely greenery or flowers.

Wood window frames are a classic addition

If there is a lot of wall space above your fireplace mantel, you may be able to add a wood window frame for additional detail. Wood window frames are a great geometric decor option for farmhouse styles. They work similarly to traditional paintings or mirrors, except they offer a more vintage and rustic look to your design scheme.

Try adding an antiqued or paint-chipped window frame above your mantel. Be sure to measure your space before purchasing this decor piece, as some window frames can be quite large. When decorating with the frame, add some greenery or small potted plants nearby for a stunning look.

vintage fireplace mantel decor with metal milk jug and candles
RooM The Agency / Adobe Stock

Candles and lanterns add a soft touch

When it comes to creating a gentle and cozy atmosphere surrounding your fireplace mantel, you can’t go wrong with incorporating a few candles or lanterns. Candles and lanterns add a touch of soft lighting that allows your space to feel relaxing and comfortable. One of the best ways to use these decor pieces in your design is to add a candelabra or two and place unscented white candles in them.

Alternatively, you can add larger candles to glass dishes and fill the bottoms with stones or glass pebbles. Use three candles in a group and place them on a shallow dish to protect your mantel for a more authentic look. You don’t have to light these candles, but the look they provide is sweet and homey. Additionally, adding large and small lanterns around your fireplace can give your space a vintage appeal.

You can’t go wrong with a bit of greenery

Of course, one of the best ways to adorn a farmhouse fireplace mantel is to use greenery. Small garlands, potted plants, flowers in vases, ferns in milk jugs, or other plant materials are a fun way to add a rustic and outdoorsy touch to your farm home. Plants make the perfect decor addition because they can be paired with everything on our list thus far and more. They help accentuate the beauty of your other decor elements, and they add a bit of liveliness to your space.

If you’re looking to add more farmhouse appeal to your fireplace mantel, these are some of the best and most popular solutions. Enhance your farmhouse mantel decor by pairing a few of these ideas together. For example, center a wood window frame on your mantel beside a couple of milk jugs filled with wildflowers. Or add some candles wrapped in green garland. No matter how you style these pieces, you’re sure to find a combination that highlights your home’s design.

Amelia Wilson
Amelia Wilson (author pen name Amelia J. Wilson) is a content writer in Greenwood, IN. She often enjoys topics on…
Less is more: 15 minimalist living room ideas to try
Try this approach with these gorgeous minimalist living room ideas
Modern and minimal Japandi styled room

Minimalist interior decorating is becoming an increasingly popular trend. This design style is all about an open layout, lots of natural light, simple furniture and finishes, and clutter-free spaces. If you are thinking of incorporating the “less is more” concept into your living room, check out these creative ideas to get you headed in the right direction.

Apartment Therapy describes minimalism as, "continuously curating your space to have a few meaningful items rather than constantly accumulating more things. This design philosophy also hinges upon cleaner, more sustainable, and more efficient ways of living and functioning."
Top 15 ideas for minimalist living

Read more
16 cozy winter decor ideas to bring charm to your home
Winter home decorating ideas for your home after the holidays are over
White background with Christmas garland and winter decor

Once the holiday season has passed and you’ve packed up your Thanksgiving and Christmas decor, your space can feel a little empty after months of decorating. Suddenly, your fireplace mantle feels lackluster and there's too much empty space where the tree sat all December. But don't fret! To overcome the air of bleakness that often arrives after packing up all the tinsel, ornaments, and Christmas adornments, why not cozy up with some charming winter decor ideas to add around the home instead?

Sure, the holiday festivities are over until next year, but that doesn't mean you can't keep decorating your home! Below are some of our favorite decor ideas to make your winter home decorating a breeze.
Pick a wintry color palette

Read more
6 fresh ideas to update your farmhouse living room for the new year
Don't give up all of your farmhouse decor — just update it
All-white modern farmhouse living room with a beadboard ceiling

The farmhouse look has been in style for home decor for quite some time now, but one of the best things about home decor is that it can evolve. If you’re looking to bring your farmhouse living room into the new year with some fresh new touches, look no further. Farmhouse decor for the new year will be less cold neutral colors and more warm neutrals and will also feature more pops of color and personality. Keep reading to find out more about how to bring your living room into the new year.
Pottery and rustic planters

One farmhouse design trend moving in for 2025 is pottery that feels weathered or has a handmade look. Anything that looks like you found it in an old barn will do (you can probably find great pieces at yard sales or flea markets). Mason jars have definitely outstayed their welcome in the farmhouse decor world, so consider replacing any mason jars that you currently have with terrain pots to update your current farmhouse living room. Also, filling a few pots with indoor plants will bring some life and pops of color to the room.
Authentic furniture

Read more