Skip to main content

Tired of pumpkins? Fall mantel decor that will put you in a Thanksgiving mood

Here are some gorgeous fall decor ideas to try no matter your style

Fall mantel
Missy Yost / Shutterstock

Fall is much more than pumpkins and Halloween. If you have a mantel and are looking to upgrade your decor, autumn provides endless opportunities. Fall mantel decor should be warm and inviting, a reflection of the feelings the season evokes. A fireplace can be the focal point of the room, and with proper decor for the fall season, you can achieve just that.

If you’re stuck in a rut of pumpkins and Halloween decorations, worry not. We have some excellent fall mantel decor ideas for you no matter what style your fireplace.

Recommended Videos

Farmhouse fall mantel

Fall mantle decor leaves and sign.
Kristen Prahl / Shutterstock

To achieve a farmhouse fall mantel, you want to consider incorporating deep greens, soft oranges, creamy whites, and even some greys. Now is also a great time to break out your farmhouse-style thankful signs and cotton sprigs. You can also incorporate a rustic turkey, country wall hangings, and a fall wreath to round out the look. Metal canisters in white to hold sprigs of foliage or an old wooden crate flipped over to hold another decorative piece will also look great.

Rustic fall mantel

Fall mantel
Missy Yost / Shutterstock

If your fireplace is already rustic, you’ll want to keep the fall decor rustic as well. Rustic decor lends itself to repurposed wood and items very well. For example, old wooden shutters flanking a wreath made of leaves is a great DIY rustic look. Repurposing an old window to back up the candles or foliage you put on the mantel is also a great idea that gives off a rustic vibe. Be sure to incorporate bright oranges, deep reds, and vibrant greens to tie everything together.

Traditional fall mantel

Pumpkins and fall flowers arranged for fall centerpieces
Deb Perry / Alamy

Just because you want to avoid pumpkins doesn’t mean you can’t still go traditional with your mantel decor. You can’t go wrong with classic fall colors like vibrant reds and oranges paired with golds and browns. Traditional leaves paired with sprigs of bright red berries and galvanized metal will create a standout mantel. Sunflowers, pinecones, and acorns are all great fillers for the areas around your candles and other pieces. Candles are super traditional and necessary for a fall mantel.

Modern fall mantel

fall rustic fireplace mantel decor
Kristen Prahl / Shutterstock

If you’re tired of the classic fall decor and your existing motif is modern, a modern fall mantel is just the thing you need. You can still use a wreath; just choose one with a leafy design in white or a monochromatic color scheme. Using colors like silver, black, cream, blush, and sage will give your mantel a fall look without using traditional shades.

Don’t be afraid to use a few live plants or dried flowers to surround your candles. Another way to achieve a modern look is to go smaller rather than larger. A small display can actually make a more significant statement than a big and busy one. For example, a few cinnamon sticks next to a candle and bourbon bottle will do the trick nicely.

Neutral fall mantel

Oksana.Bondar / Shutterstock

Neutral fall decorations are calming and relaxing, which is the exact vibe you want when in front of the fireplace, and the possibilities are extensive. Natural wood pieces, vintage pieces, and metallics such as copper will create a natural look easily.

Lots of whites, off-whites, and candles will help round out the natural look. Wheat bushels in clean glass vases paired with natural wood will also help you pull off a natural look. A wreath with light blue and green leaves hung on a mirror above the mantel will also make a statement.

Cabin-style fall mantel

Mariia Smeshkova / Shutterstock

Though it may seem like cabin-style is the same as rustic, it can be different. Keeping it simple is the key here — think antlers, chopped wood, and plaid throw blankets. Any decorations you’ve seen in a cabin in the woods will work on your mantel for fall. Wicker vases and baskets filled with spruce bows and surrounded by pinecones will give you a cabin vibe for sure. Your cabin-style mantel is also a great place to utilize any vintage pieces you may have.

Coastal fall mantel decor

candles and foliage on fireplace mantel
RooM The Agency / Adobe Stock

Coastal decor is in full swing now, and many homeowners are looking for trendy solutions to decorate their homes with this style. For fall, use wicker baskets to hold fall foliage. Alternatively, purchase or DIY glass jars wrapped in netting or jute rope to hold your autumn perennials. You might also consider adding signs in neutral tones with phrases like “thankful,” “grateful,” or “happy fall.”

Coastal decor looks gorgeous alongside many farmhouse and rustic elements, so be sure to pair these styles as you work on your design. Shell art depicting autumn leaves, fall phrases, or other seasonal motifs can also be a clever way to invite more coastal elements to the design.

Regardless of what your fireplace decor is, you can find a way to decorate your mantel for fall without falling into the jack-o-lantern and ghost trap. Halloween is a tiny portion of the autumn season, so it’s no wonder people are looking for fall decor alternatives. Don’t be afraid to stray from the expected fall decoration, and be sure to mix up colors, textures, and patterns to give your fall mantle a fresh look. Once you choose a look, you’ll be ready to snuggle up in front of the fireplace in no time.

Kelly Kaliszewski
Kelly's work has appeared in blogs and on websites. When she's not writing, she is playing with her two dogs, cooking, or…
Make the most of your living room/dining room combo with these stellar tips
Watch your living room/dining room combo shine with these tips
Gray monochrome living and dining room

Many contemporary homes have open-concept living, meaning fewer walls and shared space between rooms. It's a great idea for those who entertain or want minimal disruption between spaces. It's also good when you have small children and want to keep an eye on them while you're cooking, folding laundry, or watching TV. If you have one large area for your living room and dining room, there are some things you can do to get the most out of each room.

Of course, there's a lot to consider when it comes to which colors to choose, how to arrange furniture in a living room/dining room combo, and what wall and other decor can be used to blend the spaces together. Here's how to find the right mix that works in one collective space.
Small living room/dining room combo ideas

Read more
Our favorite Halloween mantel decor ideas that you’ll love
Try these spooky fireplace mantel ideas this year
Skull and candles Halloween decor on a table

One of the best places to decorate for Halloween is your fireplace. The fireplace is often a central or focal point of your living space and holds a lot of visual weight. Spruce up your mantel this year with these fantastic Halloween mantel decor ideas that are sure to help you find a renewed enthusiasm for the spooky season.
Do something classic

You can never go wrong with some classic Halloween decor ideas. Try these timeless setups for your fireplace mantel this year.
Use candelabras as candlesticks
Candles offer a luxe yet spooky vibe to any home. Adding some candles to your setup is a quick and effective way to decorate your fireplace mantel this fall. Visit your local antique or thrift store for vintage candelabras or candle holders. You can also order more modern designs online or from your local retail store.

Read more
9 fantastic stone fireplace decor ideas for a comfortable, nature-inspired home
Keep your home's best feature looking stylish
Stone fireplace in sitting area with dark, brown colors

One of the greatest challenges with stone fireplaces is finding decor that feels authentic while also standing out against the natural stone. You want a look that radiates comfort and coziness without coming off too cluttered or detracting from the beautiful masonry of your fireplace. So, we’ve come up with nine fantastic stone fireplace ideas to help you achieve a gorgeous look that suits your style and needs.

Your decor doesn’t have to feel tacky or out of place. Let us walk you through the best ways to decorate your stone fireplace mantel for a nature-inspired setting.
How to add a natural look to your stone fireplace

Read more