Skip to main content

Metal roof pros and cons: What you need to know

Here's why a metal roof may be right for you

Exterior of light-colored house.
Konrad Kozaczuk / Shutterstock

Shopping for a new roof isn’t always an exciting aspect of homeownership. While planning out a remodeled kitchen or refinishing your floors scratches that design itch, choosing roofing can feel like a drag. However, if your roof needs extensive repairs, you’re building a new home, or you plan to sell your property with a high ROI, you’ll need to decide which roof is best for you.

We’ll discuss everything you need to know about metal roofs, one of the most popular roof choices for many homes. We will also weigh metal roof pros and cons to help you make the best decision for your property.

Recommended Videos

What is a metal roof?

beachfront property white coastal vacation home
GregoryButler / Pixabay

Metal roofs are made of aluminum, copper, steel, or zinc, with each metal providing unique benefits and drawbacks. Steel roofing is a common choice because it is great for many environments and climates. However, aluminum and copper can be more durable alternatives that can better withstand fluctuating temperatures, heavy rain, or saltwater.

The metal is coated to offer greater protection and durability, and roof pieces are shaped into interlocking panels for installation.

Other types of roofs

Metal roofs are one of the most popular roofing choices in the U.S., following the classic asphalt shingle roof. Asphalt shingles are made of asphalt chips adhered via a tar base. They are affordable, moderately durable, and easy to replace if a few shingles get ruined in a storm.

Other roofing alternatives can include clay tiles or concrete, which are often better suited to warmer climates with limited rainfall.

Before choosing the best roofing for you, you’ll need to consider the following:

  • The environment surrounding your property and the typical weather patterns
  • If you live in a neighborhood with an HOA
  • The lifespan of your roofing choice
  • Sustainability of the materials
  • The aesthetics and how it will pair with your home

Pros of a metal roof

slim beachfront coastal house exterior
Tara Winstead / Pexels

As the second most common roofing choice in the U.S., metal roofs provide plenty of benefits that make them an excellent addition to your property.

Long lasting

Metal roofs are a long-lasting choice and can extend anywhere from 40 to 70 years, depending on your environment and regular maintenance. For comparison, shingle roofs last 15 to 50 years.

Durable

Metal roofs are considered one of the most durable roofing solutions. They can withstand high winds, fluctuating temperatures, heavy rain, and snow accumulation. Metal roofs are unlikely to crack, chip, or fade. Additionally, they have a protective coating that prevents corrosion or mold buildup.

Trendy and aesthetic

Metal roofs are trendy thanks to their modern aesthetic. They are sleek, simple, and chic. Many homeowners favor metal roofs because they come in a wide array of colors and textures, which can add a nice refresh to your home.

Sustainable

If you’re looking for a sustainable roofing solution, metal roofs are a good choice. They are often made of recycled materials and can last for several years. You’re unlikely to need many replacements until the end of the roof’s lifespan. Also, most metal roofs can be recycled at the end of their life.

More energy efficient

Metal roofs might be able to save you costs on energy bills. The metal is reflective and can send the sun’s heat away from the home, keeping the interior of the house cooler.

Cons of a metal roof

blurred house with metal roof with tree in foreground
Ushindi Namegabe / Pexels

Metal roofs are not without their drawbacks. Here are some metal roof cons to keep in mind.

Costly compared to alternatives

Metal roofs have higher upfront costs than other roofing alternatives, like shingles. However, their longevity means you’re unlikely to have to replace the roof in your lifetime.

Not all metal is ultra durable

Some metals are not as durable as others. While aluminum can be more affordable than copper, it’s not as hardy and is prone to warping in harsher environments.

Can be noisy during storms

Some metal roofs can be noisy in storms. Hail can also damage some metal roofs or cause a lot of noise.

Some metals are susceptible to rust

It’s important to research the type of metal roofs best suited for your environment. If you live near a coast, you may want to opt for a more durable metal that can withstand saltwater.

How much does a metal roof cost?

luxury large house with metal roof and long driveway
Karolina Grabowska / Pexels

Metal roofs are more expensive than shingles. You might expect to spend around $4 to $15 per square foot. Factors like your home size, the type of metal you choose, and your location will impact your cost. On average, you should spend around $10,000 for a new metal roof. However, your budget could rise as high as $30,000, depending on the factors listed above.

Metal roof vs. shingles: Which should you choose?

small suburban house with brick chimney and brown roof
Polina / Pexels

Before you decide whether to buy a metal roof vs. shingles, keep in mind your current budget and needs. If you plan to remain in your home long term, buying a metal roof that will guarantee longevity might be worth the upfront cost. However, if you’re looking to sell, a shingle roof may be just fine.

Whether you want a more sustainable solution or require a roof with more durability, metal roofs have plenty of benefits that make them a trendy alternative to the classic asphalt shingle roof. Just be sure to speak with a contractor or specialist to ensure your roofing choice is best for your location.

Amelia Wilson
Amelia Wilson (author pen name Amelia J. Wilson) is a content writer in Greenwood, IN. She often enjoys topics on…
What is enamel paint (and when should you use it)?
A tough, hard shell for all your high-traffic surfaces
Painting exterior house white

Enamel paint is a versatile and durable option for various painting projects, known for its glossy finish and long-lasting protection. Whether you're a seasoned DIY enthusiast or just looking to refresh your space, understanding what enamel paint is and when to use it can significantly impact your project's success. Let's dive into the specifics of this type of paint, explore its pros and cons, and highlight the best painting applications for this robust paint type.
What is enamel paint?

Enamel paint is a type of paint that dries to a hard, glossy finish, providing excellent durability and resistance to wear and tear. It's often used for both interior and exterior surfaces that require a tough, resilient coating. Enamel paint can be an oil-based or water-based product, with oil-based varieties offering superior durability and water-based options being more environmentally friendly and easier to clean up.

Read more
Pros and cons of gas and electric BBQ grills
Get the right tools for your summer grilling needs
Family grilling out in the backyard

Grilling out is as American as apple pie and baseball, but when it comes to electric grills vs. gas grills, everyone has an opinion. Most people have a favorite type — some even prefer charcoal grills — and all are willing to argue their points with anyone who disagrees. If you don’t already own a grill, you may be a bit overwhelmed with all of the conflicting reports as to which type is best. We're here to give you all the information you need about electric and gas grills so you can make an informed decision.

Similar to gas and electric stoves, there are pros and cons of each type of grill, and we're going to review them so the ultimate decision is easier for you to make. And once you make that purchase, you’ll be full of facts to back up your choice when the next person tries to question your grilling style.
Electric grills vs. gas grills: How do they work?

Read more
These home remodeling projects have the highest ROI, new study finds
Exterior remodels have the greatest ROI, according to a new study
For sale home sign in front of house that says "sold"

If you plan to update your home before it goes on the market, you’ll want to see this new study that details some of the best home remodeling projects with the highest return on investment (ROI). Unfortunately, home upgrades don’t always guarantee a higher resale value. So, choosing carefully which projects you invest in is important to get the greatest return.

Today, we’re sharing the best home improvement projects to tackle if you want to get the highest ROI when you sell. The top two home remodeling projects have up to 200% ROI when compared to years past, according to the study, so keep reading to learn more.
Exterior remodeling projects

Read more