Skip to main content

Are gutter guards worth it? The pros and cons you need to know

Blocking that debris isn't as straightforward as it seems

Gutter with leaves and a screen
123switch / Pixabay

When it comes to protecting your home, one of the big questions many homeowners face is, are gutter guards worth it? Gutter guards are marketed as the ultimate solution to your home’s most annoying fall home maintenance tasks, promising to keep debris out and reduce the time and money spent on upkeep. However, not everyone agrees on their value. Before deciding if gutter guards are right for your home, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons.

What are gutter guards?

Man installing gutter guards on home
FrankHH / Shutterstock

Gutter guards are devices installed over or inside gutters to prevent debris — like leaves, twigs, and other materials — from clogging your gutters. They come in various styles and materials, each designed to filter or block debris while allowing water to flow freely. Gutter guards are especially popular in areas with heavy foliage, as they help minimize the need for constant gutter cleaning.

Recommended Videos

However, as with any home improvement product, gutter guards have their advantages and drawbacks.

Pros of gutter guards

Snow blockers on home gutters
congerdesign / Pixabay

When considering the benefits of gutter guards, it’s clear that these products can be highly advantageous in the right conditions. Many find that the benefits can improve the safety, functionality, and longevity of their gutter system, leading to fewer headaches in the long run.

Prevent pest infestations

One significant benefit of gutter guards is that they can help prevent pest infestations. Without guards, gutters can collect stagnant water and debris, creating an ideal environment for pests like mosquitoes, rodents, and birds to nest. Gutter guards keep these areas clear, making it harder for pests to find places to thrive around your home.

Prevent ice dams

In colder climates, ice dams are a common problem. They form when snow melts off the roof but refreezes in the gutters, leading to blockages that can cause water to back up under shingles and even damage your home’s interior. Gutter guards can help reduce the risk of ice dams by keeping the gutters clear, allowing melted snow to flow away from the roof rather than refreezing in the gutters.

Reduce fire hazards

For those in wildfire-prone areas, gutter guards can be an additional safety feature. Dry leaves and debris trapped in gutters can be a fire risk, as embers from a nearby fire can easily ignite them. Metal gutter guards, in particular, can reduce this risk by keeping flammable material out of your gutters, thereby providing an extra layer of fire protection.

Minimize gutter blockages and water damage

One of the biggest selling points of gutter guards is their ability to reduce gutter blockages. When leaves, pine needles, and other debris collect in gutters, they block water from flowing properly, leading to potential water damage to your home’s foundation, siding, and roof. By keeping debris out, gutter guards help minimize these risks and protect your home from water damage.

Lengthen the life of your gutters

Since gutter guards reduce the amount of debris in your gutters, they also reduce the wear and tear on the system. Without regular blockages and standing water, gutters are less likely to corrode, sag, or pull away from the home. This protection can extend the life of your gutter system, making it a worthwhile investment over time.

Cons of gutter guards

man on a ladder cleaning rain gutters
Greg McGill / Shutterstock

While gutter guards come with many benefits, they are not a one-size-fits-all solution. Several factors might make gutter guards less desirable, depending on your specific home needs and budget. Understanding these drawbacks can help you decide if they’re worth it for you.

Require regular maintenance

Despite the design’s aim to reduce maintenance, gutter guards do require upkeep. Over time, dirt, dust, and small particles can build up on the guards themselves, reducing their effectiveness. This requires occasional cleaning to keep them functioning well, which means you’re not entirely free from gutter maintenance.

Gutters still require cleaning

Even with gutter guards in place, gutters may still need periodic cleaning. Small debris, such as pine needles or fine particles, can sometimes slip through the guards and accumulate over time. While gutter guards will reduce the frequency of cleaning, they won’t eliminate it entirely, especially if you live in an area with significant tree coverage.

Installation costs

Gutter guard installation can be costly, especially if you opt for high-quality materials or hire professionals. Although they can reduce maintenance needs, the initial investment can be significant, which may deter some homeowners. For those on a budget, it’s important to weigh whether the long-term savings justify the upfront costs.

Types of gutter guards to consider

Screen type gutter guard rolled up on a home's gutter
J.J. Gouin / Shutterstock

If you decide to invest in gutter guards, there are several types available. Each type offers unique advantages, and choosing the right one depends on your needs, the type of debris in your area, and your budget.

  • Screen guards: Made from wire or plastic, screen guards are simple and affordable. They fit over the gutter to block larger debris but may require frequent cleaning if smaller particles slip through.
  • Mesh guards: Similar to screens but with finer openings, mesh guards offer improved filtration and can block smaller debris, although they are generally more expensive than basic screen guards.
  • Reverse curve guards: These guards are designed to push debris over the edge while allowing water to flow into the gutter. They are effective but can be visible from the ground and may interfere with the roofline and your home’s curb appeal.
  • Foam guards: Placed inside the gutter, foam guards allow water to pass through while blocking debris. They are easy to install but may require frequent replacement due to exposure to the elements.
  • Brush guards: Resembling large pipe cleaners, brush guards fit inside the gutters and block leaves while allowing water to flow. They are a cost-effective option, but can require regular cleaning and removal of trapped debris.

So, are gutter guards worth it? The answer depends on your specific needs, environment, and willingness to invest in long-term home maintenance. Gutter guards can offer substantial benefits, but also come with drawbacks. Ultimately, understanding the pros and cons will help you make the best choice for your home and your needs.

Veronica Sparks
Veronica Sparks is a writer from Milwaukee, Wisconsin who loves writing about gardening, home décor, and DIY life. She’s…
The pros and cons of marble countertops to know before you buy
We'll weigh the benefits and disadvantages of installing this stone
Modern white kitchen with quartz counters

Marble countertops add an exquisite touch to many modern homes. However, this gorgeous stone isn’t without its faults. Today, we'll discuss the pros and cons of marble countertops to help you make the right decision for your space.
Benefits of having marble countertops

There are several benefits to having marble countertops in your kitchen. Let's explore them.
Aesthetics
The allure of marble countertops makes them a highly sought-after addition to many kitchens nationwide. With various colors, patterns, and veining, marble counters offer homeowners a chance to customize their space and create luxe aesthetics.

Read more
These are the best shower plants for your bathroom (and why you really need one)
These plants have design and health benefits for your shower
Woman in a tub next to a plant

Keeping indoor plants has been popular in interior design for years, but this nature-inspired decor has gone to a whole new level in recent years. From green paint being a top color choice to design styles adopting a "friluftsliv" appeal, designers and homeowners alike are finding new and interesting ways to incorporate nature into the modern home. What's one of our favorite green design trends right now? The shower plant.

Whether you have a bathroom with a green palette or a super luxurious, modern bathroom design, keeping a plant inside your shower is a unique and fun design approach. Did you know that it's also incredibly beneficial for your health? These are the benefits of a shower plant — and the best ones you can get.
What are the benefits of shower plants?

Read more
Do you need to wash walls before painting? The honest truth
What you need to know before starting your painting project
Gloved hand cleaning crayon off wall with a Magic Eraser

While many mistakes can be made during a DIY painting project, one question many homeowners ask is whether they really need to wash walls before painting. It's a cumbersome task, so is it really necessary? The answer is yes. Having a clean, dry wall before slapping down that primer and paint can prevent all sorts of cosmetic and even health issues down the road.

Of course, there are some rooms in your house that need a more thorough cleaning than others. If you're ready to paint, here's how you should wash your walls first.
Really? Do you need to wash walls before painting?

Read more